Which of these characters wasn't a villian in Club Penguin?

The character that wasn't a villain in Club Penguin is The Director. Unlike other characters such as Herbert P. Bear, Tusk, and Protobot who were known for their villainous actions in trying to disrupt and take over the island, The Director played a more neutral role. He was the head of the EPF (Elite Penguin Force) and was mainly focused on the safety and well-being of the island's inhabitants. The Director often guided players through missions and provided valuable information, making him an ally rather than a villain in Club Penguin.